Can a cash pay PT business add revenue without charging $200 a visit? Paul Martin sits down with Gina Vitale, a licensed physical therapist assistant, on sliding scales and how PT assistants can run back school, runner's clinics and other programs that bring new clients in.
Generated from the episode audio and lightly edited for readability.
I will tell you that back in the dark ages, 1994 starting treating patients, double booking was not ever a thing.
Gina Vitale has been a licensed physical therapy assistant since nineteen ninety-four. has more than thirty years of hands-on patient care experience. And today, she runs a company called Gina Vitale Writes, and that's a health content business. She writes for Nationwide Children's Hospital and many others. She is here today to give owners somewhat of a view from inside the clinic. I know she has a lot of great things to talk about.
So Gina, welcome.
Thank you.
So we talk about double booking and short staffing, scheduling barriers. How much of that in, clinics that accept insurance comes back to what insurance is willing to pay providers per visit?
I will tell you that back in the dark ages, 1994 starting treating patients, double booking was not ever a thing. They started limiting how many visits someone could have per, diagnosis.
And so when those changes started happening, we had to start changing how we did things in the clinic, right? And then, and I don't even know when this started, it's probably more like 15 years ago, the, reimbursement for services starting being cut back.
It almost seemed like annually they were like, "Okay, now this, this service is only worth this amount of money, and last year it was worth this amount of money." Now we're gonna have to have more people in the clinic in order to make the overhead
So it started this sort of like culture of this is what we need to do to survive, as a business. And so that meant on payers who could, would allow or didn't have any limitations on two people in the same hour or half hour or whatever, then those people started to be double booked, triple booked, things of that sort, right?
You just have this trickle-down effect, right? Where after so long of doing that and therapists probably feeling like, you're running from patient to patient you're handing off to a tech,
Leading to, burnout and then, sometimes people just leave because they just, they don't feel like they're giving quality care, like that's not what they got into therapy for,
What's your perspective on how low insurance continues to reimburse for therapy services, which has forced a lot of the double booking overlap of patients utilization of techs, utilization of PT assistants, who I am very much in favor of. But a lot of that is due to how little insurance reimburses physical therapists
Insurance is definitely devaluing services.
So Gina, you've said that cash pay shuts out patients who want and need physical therapy. In your experience, who are those patients that are getting shut out by cash-based pay?
And especially in probably the last maybe 10 years of treating I worked in very lower income areas.
Super blue-collar even lots of immigrant folks who, they're just trying to make ends meet. And so if you offer in an area purely a cash-based option for physical therapy those are the kind of folks that you are excluding. They don't have extra money after, paying the rent, buying groceries and paying the light bill, paying the water bill.
What other options would you recommend that could be offered to patients or as you had called them earlier, clients that have that need but don't have obviously the funds to support and to pay for high-paid cash-based services?
So I, one of the options and I haven't seen this in a therapy clinic necessarily I've seen it in other health businesses is offering maybe a sliding scale. And someone comes in, they want and need physical therapy. They don't have $200. Through, some sort of, I don't know what, questionnaire or whatever, they meet this criteria where, maybe they pay, half of that, or they pay it on a almost like a payment plan or something that's manageable for them, right?
Meeting that person where they are in life to help them get the care that they need
Those physical therapists are under that pressure that they have to absolutely perform every single patient every single minute of every single day because that person is reaching in their pocket and, paying them for that service. and I think that's why we've seen cash-based practices not have the ability to scale like an insurance-based practice
But, what if they offered, little side pieces to bring folks in for other reasons than physical therapy,
As an assistant talk about some of the services that you're able to provide that people are able to pay for. And it would appear that it is at a level that people are able to get outcomes as well as not pay $200 a visit. Talk to us a little bit about that
Yeah. As PTAs can do, basically all of the same treatment and exercise for a session than, a PT can. We just can't do the evaluation and, kinda like the final assessment discharge thing, right? If you have a cash-based business and you have a PTA in the clinic, and there's, maybe you're gonna hand off one or two folks, but the majority of the folks you're gonna keep.
A PTA can offer, like in-clinic, like back school, right? Body mechanics, here's the basic maybe it's a, a monthly or a weekly session of here's the best exercises for a basic back strain. Here's good body mechanics. And teaching and having people go through, setting up a lift station and things of that sort.
On the education front PTAs, that's literally what we do for an entire session for the most part, right? We're educating the patient all the time. So you know, something like, body mechanics training and a back school would be one thing. Sport-specific training, if that's in your genre, that's in your realm.
You have one night a week, a runner's clinic, you look at running form. You maybe these are some good things to do if, you have, a chronic Achilles tendonitis or something
They're specialists. They don't have to do the eval part of the program, so they're specialists in all of the follow-up and all the follow-up exercises as well as carrying out a plan of care.
Exactly. Decipher that plan of care. Okay, here's my plan of attack. Here's how I'm gonna work with this patient the first few visits.
I think cash-based practices, are really able to expand with the model that you just described,
We just came up with the perfect utilization for a PT assistant or exercise specialists in a cash-based practice.
I'm a big believer in PT assistants and the value that PT assistants bring, not to just the business and the practice, but the value the PT assistants can give to patients
Awesome. We just fixed something. How about that?
If any of you out there today have a question for Gina or myself on this topic, just click below and let's talk. Thank you for joining us, and I look forward to seeing you next time.